Energy Bars vs Gels

Greetings to all,

I have been having questions of how/when to go for bars and gels.
On one side, I like the “food” feeling of having a bar but I prefer by far the energy delivery of gels. Maybe it is because they are easier to time; one every hour and you feel the effects almost immediately.Then I wonder, why go for bars when I am looking to feel good and perform?

With that said,what I would like to clarify (and need your help for) is; why, when and how to go for a bar over a gel and vice-versa.

Also, how to choose one brand over another? There are so many out there and most have organic and vegan options so these criteria are no longer show stoppers.

Thanks to all,

It depends :slight_smile:
On a group ride I tend to go with the bars for the first couple of hours and then switch to gels for the last couple of hours.
Bar and gel brands - it is a try it and see. Try out different ones on the indoor trainer or on shorter rides as you’ll want to see how your body takes to different types and also what you like in flavours, but to not get on with one indoors then out on a long ride.

2 Likes

There are two answers to this:

  1. Which do you tolerate better under high stress? I know folks who cannot tolerate gels at that level and others who cannot tolerate any form of food.
  2. What is the purpose of your ride? If you need energy FAST, gels are the way to go (actually, a high blend drink mix like CarboRocket might be better suited but you didn’t mention this). If you are on a five to six hour endurance ride and you need a slow burn, bars or better yet (and if you can tolerate it) rice cakes with something mixed in.
    Now, if you need to recover from low blood sugar (aka, the Bonk), gels are the preferred way to bring up your blood sugar quickly. Follow that with a bar to sustain.
3 Likes

When I’m out for a long ride at an endurance/low tempo pace I can eat whole foods. Bars, skratchlabs rice crispy squares or bars.

But when I’m under a lot of stress I can’t chew and breath as easily,. Then I switch to gels or Skratch labs superfuel. I prefer superfuel because I can grab a bottle easily, reaching into my jersey and opening a gel can be a challenge in a fast-moving group.

2 Likes

Chewing a bar and heavy breathing at the same time. That really is not fun. I was on a ride once where a photographer caught me eating, open mouthed. Not pleasant :slight_smile:

3 Likes

I have never heard of CarboRocket, actually never seen it here in france. Took a quick look online and it packs power! 82g of carbs per serving!

I take bars and gels together. I eat bars when riding at a lower intensity and gels at a higher tempo. On a long fast 6+ hour endurance ride I usually start by eating bars and then switch to gels later on. All taken alongside a water/energy mix.

As for which brand to choose, I look for the most natural and least processed ingredients and preferably organic. They also have to taste good! I personally like Veloforte as a brand, but they are UK only.

1 Like

Just tried TORQ for the first time. The Apple Crumble Gel has a pretty good taste.

1 Like

Also recently introduced is Skratch Superfuel. I’m looking for single servings before I commit a lot of funds to it. 86g carbs per bidon.

1 Like

The TORQ gels are pretty good, probabaly the only gels that don’t taste like some kind of chemical toilet cleaner!

1 Like

I eat Clif bars on the bike for easier rides.

I make my own drink mix, its much, much cheaper than Torq/SiS etc. Studies have shown the body is capable of taking on over 100g carbs/hr.

I find as I have gotten fitter and FTP is higher, taking on carbs during intense sessions is more important as the total calorific deficit is greater at the end of a session. Team Scream for example is a 1060kj workout now so taking on ~300kcal of carbs intra-workout really lowers the RPE and means I don’t feel like I have to empty the fridge after harder sessions.

1 Like

I go for food first, (bars) and use gels as a get out of jail food, some of the longer tougher suff workouts just need energy fast so gels may have a place

1 Like

If you want a smile, I was running marathons when gels first came on the scene.Not having pockets, I pinned a couple of gels to my shorts, they flapped about so I stuffed them inside my shorts. Unfortunately, the gels leaked .It was almost impossible to get my shorts off to shower at the end of the race my dangly bits and shorts had solidified together

1 Like

Gels are usually all carbs; bars often hav some protein in them. According to my reading about fueling, for any ride of 2 hours or less, carb only drinks/gels are good. But for 3 hours or more, a bar with a little protein - 1 gram of protein for every 7-10 grams of carbs is better than just carbs. Most electrolyte/fuel drinks are all carbs, but there are endurance drinks with protein in them for long rides and ultra runners. When you push your body hard enough for long enough, it will start to break down muscle tissue, so the protein in the bar/drink helps prevent that. Personally, I find Lara bars and Clif bars work well. They are not too gooey, so I can break them into smaller pieces and eat them a little bit at a time. Plus my stomach is happy with them.

2 Likes

@wmalexmann That last statement is REALLY important. The last thing you want to do in the Peloton is heave. The next worst is the break in The Rookie that the rider has to take…(visiting the Loo whilst riding is not a fun event, no matter the consistency).